Vise Review: PhotoMath; The App That Can Solve Math Sums… But Can It?

5

PhotoMath is a very interesting app in theory. Yes, it would be great to get help on your math homework from your smartphone. Yes, it would be convenient if that app could assist you through a simple picture of the problem. And yes, it would be beneficial for said app to give step by step instructions on how to solve the problem. These are all things PhotoMath does, at least in theory. However, while the app looks great and, in a sense, functions perfectly well, there are some major flaws that must be addressed before it can be considered a quality app.

PhotoMath – THE GOOD

PhotoMath
PhotoMath has a simple and intuitive design that works great on the surface

PhotoMath really does have a straight forward set-up. It takes on a more minimalist design so that it may better focus on the functionality of the app, which is great. I like the fact that the app isn’t tacked on with needless bells and whistles. Taking pictures of math problems was also very easy. The app does not actually require you to snap the picture. Once a math problem is presented in the given field, the app automatically scans it and give you the solution/steps to solve it. It takes out a rather tedious step and further streamlines the already streamlined process.

THE NOT SO GOOD PART

While PhotoMath does pick up fairly well and automatically scans problems, it has hit and miss results. When I tried to scan a problem directly from my computer (with an IPS display), it scanned the problem three different times… and gave me three different answers. It seems PhotoMath sometimes has difficulty detecting every element of a math problem (or in some cases adds in components that don’t exist). The issue is less apparent when scanning problems on paper (Problems on paper must be printed. As of this post the app does not support handwritten problems) but it is annoying. PhotoMath is still a relatively new app, so it can be understood that there are still some bugs to work out. However there are certain issues that must be addressed before users truly consider this a helpful app.

For example, certain blogs and reviews have reported that PhotoMath provides blatantly wrong answers to math problems. There are also criticisms saying that PhotoMath takes convoluted and unnecessary steps in order to reach the correct solution to the problem. Couple these two issues with a host of other criticisms, and the app doesn’t seem quite as effective.

THE APP VERDICT

As of right now, PhotoMath isn’t usable, at least in a practical sense. Yes, it is kind of fun to play with, but it is not reliable for helping solve math problems in a practical setting such as school. PhotoMath really only excels at the simplest of equations, which is something no one should need a smartphone to solve for them.

But, perhaps it is a good thing PhotoMath doesn’t work because if anything, assistant apps such as this may teach students to become dependent on technology to solve their problems rather than their own mental capacities. Apps such as this one could make students complacent, which will stifle creativity and ingenuity.  Not that any teacher worth their merit would really allow students to use their phones during math class.

You might also like

5
Leave a Reply

avatar
3 Comment threads
2 Thread replies
1 Followers
 
Most reacted comment
Hottest comment thread
4 Comment authors
PhotomathMYUNG ROSATINevenMichela Smith Recent comment authors

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

  Subscribe  
Notify of
Photomath
Guest
Photomath

Hey,

I’d say Photomath is at least better then any other apps in the market.

MYUNG ROSATI
Guest
MYUNG ROSATI

Very nice and informative article here Caleb! I agree that As of right now, PhotoMath isn’t usable, at least in a practical sense. Yes, it is kind of fun to play with, but it is not reliable for helping solve math problems in a practical setting such as school. PhotoMath… Read more »

Michela Smith
Guest
Michela Smith

Its meant to solve things on paper. The fact it does what it does is great, but not everything is perfect

Michela Smith
Guest
Michela Smith

It excels in more than simple math. I use it in algebra.

Neven
Guest

I like photomath, especially version 2.0 – it does a decent problem on simple Algebra 1 and Algebra 2 equations, and simplifying expressions. However there are a lot of problems for which the solution is provided, but not the steps (for example factoring). There are other systems around (without photo… Read more »

DON’T MISS OUT!
Subscribe To Newsletter
Be the first to get latest updates and exclusive content straight to your email inbox.
STAY UPDATED
Give it a try, you can unsubscribe anytime.
close-link

Enjoying this article? Please spread the word.

close-link